Rabbi's Section
Rabbi Rose
Rabbi David Rose was born in New Zealand where he obtained a BA in Political Science and History. He was the National Head of Bnei Akiva in New Zealand. He obtained Rabbinical Ordination from the Chief Rabbinate of Israel, where he lived for 10 years, before moving to Sweden where he helped set up an educational project. He served as the Rabbi of Richmond Synagogue, Surrey for 4 years, and obtained an MA in Jewish studies from UCL. He was appointed to his current post in Edinburgh in May 2003. Rabbi Rose represents the Jewish community in several civic forums, is a member of the Conference of Scottish Religious Leaders and is Honorary President of the Edinburgh Interfaith Association.
As well as teaching at the Cheder, he also conducts Adult Education classes, mostly online.
Each week he produces his own Parsha sheet for the weekly sedra, titled ‘Forth Light’. This usually includes a challenging “Parsha Puzzle”.
If you have any questions for Rabbi Rose, then please contact the Rabbi.
Forth Light – this week’s Torah commentary
Parshat Va’era
History Divine and human
Many books, both fiction and non-fiction begin with the an initial page at the beginning outlining the dramatis personae or characters in the story. This is done in order for the reader to keep track of who is who in the story and to understand the characters’ backgrounds and motivations. The Torah also sometimes provides such introductions, as in the details on Abram and Sarai’s families or the narrative surrounding the birth of Jacob’s children or, later in the Bible, Samson and Samuel.
One of the more manifest examples of this phenomenon occurs this week, when the Torah takes time out of the narrative of redemption in order to give us the genealogy of Moses and his immediate family, all of whom will be significant in the story to follow. What is interesting is that this introduction occurs in the middle of the narrative. Moses has already been introduced to us and accepted and begun his mission and initially failed, before we learn who his parents actually are. His brother and sister are also introduced to us without any detail concerning their background or family situation. These details are only revealed to us now in a break separating Moses’ initial unsuccessful efforts and G-d’s direct interference by means of the plagues.
What is the reason for this strange positioning? If it was important for us to know the background of the dramatis personae, then this should have been revealed to us before or shortly after Moses’ birth. If it is not particularly relevant to know this information, it should have been omitted. Is there significance in the fact that it is revealed precisely at the point that Moses’ initial endeavours have failed and Divine power will start to come into to play?
It is possible to understand this positioning as teaching us an important lesson about the interplay between divine action and human endeavour. Precisely at the beginning of the narrative where Moses and others seem to act on their own initiative and G-d is not mentioned, their antecedents are not mentioned in order to highlight the hidden Divine hand behind events. In contradistinction, it is precisely before G-d’s hand is openly revealed, that the human actors in the drama are accorded their proper detailed debut. It is as if the Torah is emphasising to us that while normal human efforts can often conceal Divine agency, even open Divine intervention in history needs human actors to take it forward. Human history is presented as neither simply the result of human action nor Divine agency but rather the interaction between the two. That is as true today as it was then and thus the positioning of Moses’ genealogy contains a message also for our time and situation.